UPDATE: White House Outlines Tax Changes On Offshore Income
May 11 2009 - 2:21PM
Dow Jones News
The White House on Monday unveiled a $210 billion plan to tax
more of U.S. firms' overseas earnings and crack down on tax
avoidance - including a new measure to shut down a tax maneuver by
foreign hedge funds.
In the hedge fund transactions, U.S. banks including Lehman
Brothers Holdings Inc. (LEH), Morgan Stanley (MS) and Citigroup
Inc. (C) used complex swaps to help foreign investors reap the
benefits of investing in the U.S. stock market, without having to
pay a 30% withholding tax.
That proposal is just one aspect of a number of tax changes the
Obama administration would make affecting U.S.-related income that
moves across national borders. President Barack Obama is looking to
reduce the deficit and pay for pricy new domestic programs, and he
has long made clear he believes the U.S. international tax rules
are ridden with loopholes and need fixing.
Most of the money that would be raised from tax changes in the
international area - $189.5 billion out of a total $210 billion -
would come from proposals Obama announced last week to tax more of
firms' foreign profits. U.S. companies say the proposals would
hamper their ability to compete in the global marketplace.
Jeffrey H. Paravano, chair of the tax group at the Baker &
Hostetler law firm, said that when taken together, the Obama tax
proposals would be expected to raise the effective tax rate of a
U.S. multinational by about 6%. That would mean an effective tax
rate of 32% for one company his firm advises, he said.
Paravano said he is troubled by the fact that Obama is not
proposing to reduce the statutory corporate tax rate as part of his
bid to root loopholes out of the code. "It's great to close tax
loopholes if you're going to reduce the rate generally," he said.
"If not, U.S. companies' effective tax rates will go so high that
we can no longer compete."
A Treasury Dept. official briefing reporters on the proposals
Monday said the Obama administration is trying to "strike a
balance" on overseas income between keeping U.S. firms competitive
and removing tax code distortions that might cause a firm to
"invest in Malaysia instead of Michigan."
The Obama tax proposals do not include a plan to limit foreign
insurers' ability to reinsure their own policies - a practice some
Capitol Hill Democrats allege is done to avoid U.S. taxes. That is
a victory for foreign insurers including Swiss Re and ACE Limited
(ACE), and a defeat for U.S. proponents like W.R. Berkley Corp.
(WRB) and Chubb Corp. (CB).
The Treasury official said that omission should not be
interpreted to mean that Obama has taken a position on the
reinsurance issue. "We are still reviewing that and have not yet
come to a decision on it," said the official.
The proposal affecting hedge fund dividend swaps was championed
by Sen. Carl Levin, D-Mich.
Another new proposal would restrict income shifting by a U.S.
company to a foreign subsidiary, by transferring intangible
property like patents or goodwill.
Another would repeal the ability of U.S. companies that derive
at least 80% of their income from foreign business to treat
interest and dividends as exempt from U.S. withholding tax.
A plan to disallow foreign tax credits for some U.S. firms that
pay a special levy to a foreign jurisdiction in exchange for an
economic benefit, would raise $4.5 billion over 10 years.
Besides the international tax measures, the Obama budget
proposes $735.5 billion in tax cuts for individuals over the next
10 years, which have been announced previously.
The primary item, the "making work pay tax credit," would
deliver a $535 billion tax cut through 2019 for qualifying
individuals; the expanded child tax credit for lower income
families would deliver $70.9 billion in tax relief while the
expanded saver's tax credit and automatic enrollment in IRAs would
provide $59.6 billion in relief.
-By Martin Vaughan, Dow Jones Newswires; 202-862-9244;
martin.vaughan@dowjones.com