Apple Inc. (AAPL) board members on Wednesday defended the
company's disclosure last month of a medical leave by Chief
Executive Steve Jobs, and said he remains deeply involved in the
company's strategic matters.
Jobs' absence from the company's shareholder meeting Wednesday
underscored the prospect of leadership succession at the computer
maker.
After the meeting, some shareholders expressed frustration at
the board's refusal to disclose more than what is already known
about the company's succession plans, and Jobs' health. The board
also didn't respond to questions about an investigation by
securities regulators into how the company handled the health
disclosures.
"I'm disappointed the board was not more forthcoming," said
Brandon Rees, a representative of the AFL-CIO Reserve Fund, which
owns a significant amount of Apple stock. Louis Malizia, assistant
capital strategies director for the International Brotherhood of
Teamsters, shared the sentiment.
"I feel like I don't know any more than I did," he said.
The annual meeting, held at Apple's Cupertino, Calif.,
headquarters, marked the first time shareholders have had a chance
to quiz board members directly since Jobs said in mid-January he
was pursuing medical treatment that would require him to take time
off work. Except for a brief statement at the time, the board has
been silent on the matter, despite criticism from some
investors.
The announcement raised the prospect of a change in leadership
at the company.
"We believe we have met all disclosure obligations," Genentech
Inc. (DNA) CEO Arthur Levinson told shareholders. Levinson has been
an Apple board member since 2000. "Nothing has changed. Succession
planning is something this board takes up regularly. You can assume
we will do that responsibly."
"I'm confident in the future of the company," added Apple Chief
Operating Officer Tim Cook, who has assumed many of Jobs'
day-to-day duties in his absence.
The meeting is the first that Jobs, a co-founder of the company,
has missed in a decade. In addition to Jobs' absence, Google Inc.
(GOOG) CEO and Apple board member Eric Schmidt wasn't at the
meeting.
News about Jobs' health, which has been a concern since he
disclosed he had been treated successfully for pancreatic cancer,
has moved Apple's stock price. Jobs, 54 years old, is considered
integral to the company's success and is credited with reviving the
company upon his return about 12 years ago.
At Wednesday's meeting, Jobs was re-elected to the board of
directors, as were seven other members. Although Jobs was absent,
shareholders sang "Happy Birthday" to him, as he celebrated his
birthday earlier this week.
The give-and-take between board members and shareholders went
little beyond what is already known about Jobs' health. Similarly,
little news was given on succession plans for the company's top
leadership.
In recent trading, Apple shares were up 2.7% at $92.71. Apple's
shares have fallen by more than 50% since hitting their all-time
high of $202.96 on Dec. 28, 2007.
The board faces a difficult challenge balancing the needs of
shareholders on one hand with concerns over Jobs' privacy on the
other. Jobs is notoriously reluctant to share details about his
health.
Apple shareholders have called for more details on Jobs' health,
as well as the company's succession plans, because of the outsized
role Jobs plays at the company. Few CEOs are as important to their
companies or so closely identified with them as Jobs is with Apple.
The executive is considered both the face of Apple and its chief
innovator. For example, Jobs is cited as the lead author of Apple's
all-encompassing patent for its hit iPhone.
On Jan. 5, Apple shares rose almost 2% after Jobs confirmed
months of rumors that he had suffered a health setback because he
said the condition was easily treatable. Shares began falling when
Jobs announced nine days later that the treatment he was seeking
was more complex and he would need to take a leave of absence until
June. They fell up to 5% after reports the Securities and Exchange
Commission has begun investigating whether Apple disclosed the
health difficulties in a timely fashion.
Apple's board, which includes former Vice President Al Gore, has
been silent since a brief note on Jan. 5, even though pressure has
been on them to say something. Board members have either declined
to comment or failed to return requests for comment on the
situation.
In Jobs' absence, Apple has pushed other executives, namely
Chief Operating Officer Tim Cook and Senior Vice President Phil
Schiller, as the public faces of the company. That's helped to
soothe some investors worried about whether the company has the
bench strength to move ahead without Jobs, and the stock has
rallied, though many remain anxious for information about his
health.
"There are still some concerns about that," Shaw Wu, an analyst
at Kaufman Brothers, said of Jobs' health status. "Many people see
it as a private matter, but on the other hand, he's such an
important part of the company."
Intuit Inc. (INTU) Chairman William Campbell, an Apple director
since 1997, and Levinson were chosen as co-lead directors.
Also re-elected were Jobs, a board member since 1997; Gore, a
board member since 2003; J. Crew Group Inc. (JCG) Chief Executive
Millard Drexler, a director since 1999; Avon Products Inc. (AVP)
Chief Executive Andrea Jung, a director since 2008; Schmidt, a
director since 2006; and venture capitalist Jerome York, a member
since 1997.
A request for Apple to allow shareholders to express their
opinion on senior executive compensation was voted down. So were
proposals for Apple to be more transparent about corporate
political donations, to call for universal health care and to
disclose more about its carbon footprint.
-By Ben Charny, Dow Jones Newswires; 415-765-8230;
ben.charny@dowjones.com