BEIJING (AFP)--An antiques collector who apparently sabotaged a
Paris auction of two Chinese relics earned praise in China Tuesday
as a patriot but also criticism for sullying the nation's
reputation.
In the state-controlled media and on the more liberal Internet,
debate raged over 44-year-old Cai Mingchao's decision to bid
successfully for the bronze animal heads, only to declare he
wouldn't pay for them.
"A collector and a patriot," the English-language China Daily
called him on its front page.
A vote on the Web site of China News Service, a news agency
under the control of the cabinet, showed 8,347, or 63%, in favor of
Cai's action.
At the other end of the spectrum, Cai was branded a con man and
misguided.
"There are many ways to love your country. But you absolutely
cannot use trust to cheat people," said one entry on the popular
Baidu Web site.
Zhao Yu, a senior culture ministry official, told the Beijing
Times that Cai's behavior during and after last week's Christie's
auction had done his compatriots no favor.
"In overseas auctions...bidders usually need no deposit and
simply rely on their reputation," Zhao said.
"The fact that Cai Mingchao has gone back on his word in reality
means he has undermined the credibility enjoyed by Chinese people
at large international auctions."
The two bronze heads were looted from an imperial palace in
Beijing at the end of the second Opium War in 1860, which remains a
potent focus for nationalist sentiment in China.
The bronzes, part of the art collection of late French fashion
designer Yves Saint Laurent and his partner, Pierre Berge, sold for
EUR15.7 million ($19.9 million) each at the Christie Group Plc
(CTG.LN), or Christie's, auction in Paris.
Chinese authorities had repeatedly demanded the sale not go
ahead, and angry reaction from government officials after they were
sold featured prominently in the domestic media until Cai's
admission Monday.
However, it remained unclear Tuesday whether Cai, a wealthy
antiques dealer with a history of paying millions of dollars for
Chinese artifacts, would indeed renege on the deal.
He has until Wednesday to pay and neither he nor the
organization backing him, the National Treasures Fund, would
comment.
China Daily said the decision to back out of the sale could be
expensive for Cai. It quoted a legal expert as saying he could be
asked to pay the commission on the sale, estimated at EUR7
million.
"Theoretically, Cai is required to pay for the auction objects
at the price agreed," Wang Fenghai, chief lawyer at the China
Association of Auctioneers, told China Daily.
"In case (he fails to do that), he is supposed to bear
liabilities for default or, with the consent of the ex-owner,
Christie's may put the items up for auction again."
The Chinese foreign ministry Tuesday denied any involvement in
the much-publicized case.
"As for the involvement of relevant individuals in the auction
of the bronze sculptures, I personally, and the State
Administration of Cultural Heritage, knew nothing about it,"
ministry spokesman Qin Gang told reporters.
"Therefore, I will not comment on this unofficial behavior."
Meanwhile, millions of Chinese were left pondering the merits of
Cai's actions.
"It was Christie's that started violating the rules," said Wang
Zhanyang, a professor at the Central Socialist Academy, according
to Beijing News.