Hovnanian Will Soon See Outcome Of High-Stakes Hudson Gamble
June 10 2009 - 2:38PM
Dow Jones News
Hovnanian Enterprises Inc. (HOV) is about to learn if its
high-rise gamble pays off.
Back in the boom, the home builder launched its biggest tower, a
48-story, 420-unit condo tower in Jersey City, N.J., offering Big
Apple views just feet from the Hudson River.
But the market deteriorated dramatically during construction,
and, with closings expected to start within the next month, it's
likely some contracted buyers won't make it to the closing table.
That could mean cancellations and fights over deposits as the
company - which has seen 11 consecutive quarterly losses and its
shares plunge by more than 60% in the 12 months - works to unload
inventory in an ailing market battered by financial turmoil.
What's more, Hovnanian can't turn the project into a rental
tower, said Marty McKenna, spokesman for Equity Residential (EQR),
which is finishing and seeing strong demand for 480 apartments that
share common areas including the pool deck and the parking garage
with 77 Hudson.
Red Bank, N.J.-based Hovnanian, the nation's sixth-largest
builder by annual closings, could be preparing itself. In its
recent second-quarter results, the market came up as it discussed
its eye-popping land-related charges of roughly $319 million.
"Impairments in the Northeast are due to recent weaknesses in
this market primarily in the suburbs of Manhattan, which is a
direct result of recent increases in unemployment in that market,
especially as it relates to Wall Street," the company said in its
June 3 conference call. " ...The New York City market held up much
longer than other markets during this downturn, but with the perils
of the financial market sector that really hit home in the fall of
2008, the declines in this market have occurred rapidly."
Like most builders, the company does not break out impairments
by community.
Hovnanian did say that it recorded $8.7 million of write-downs
associated with its investment in joint ventures, which show up on
the income statement's loss from unconsolidated joint ventures
line. "This joint venture where we had a write-down is in New
Jersey and is also on the Hudson River waterfront with views of
Manhattan," said Chief Financial Officer J. Larry Sorsby in the
earnings conference call.
Hovnanian previously said Strategic Real Estate Advisors advised
a joint-venture partner on the project, where prices now start in
the $300,000 range. Hovnanian would not reveal the partner. It
does, however, have a second joint venture on the Hudson, and would
not say Wednesday if this impairment was for 77 Hudson.
Hovnanian isn't the only home builder better known for
single-family construction selling condos in this Garden State
market. Toll Brothers Inc. (TOL) just announced that, at its
12-story, 230-unit 700 Grove project in Jersey City, buyers can get
in for 3.5% down - as little as $17,500 - through new Federal
Housing Administration qualified loans.
"FHA is a big selling point," said Ben Jogodnik, senior vice
president for Toll's City Living division in Hoboken and Jersey
City.
The development is more than 85% sold and closed, making it
eligible for loans guaranteed by government-backed mortgage
agencies Freddie Mac (FRE) and Fannie Mae (FNM), he added.
In March, Hovnanian said 77 Hudson was not eligible, but it was
offering competitive rates through various partnerships.
It could not say Wednesday if that has changed.
- By Dawn Wotapka; Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-5248;
dawn.wotapka@dowjones.com