Direct Edge Moves Ahead In Bid For U.S. Exchange Status
September 14 2009 - 11:32AM
Dow Jones News
The head of Direct Edge said Monday that its formal application
for exchange status would make the U.S. equity trading operator
more profitable and bolster its industry standing.
Direct Edge is already the third-largest venue for trading U.S.
equities, and Chief Executive William O'Brien said that the planned
conversion to an exchange would also allow it to explore new asset
classes and expand its geographical reach.
The company is the latest in the new breed of electronic trading
platforms to seek formal exchange status. Rival BATS Trading, which
has also chipped away the market share of incumbents NYSE Euronext
(NYX) and Nasdaq OMX Group Inc. (NDAQ), converted in October
2008.
Direct Edge's applications, filed in May, were published Monday
on the Securities and Exchange Commission's Web site, detailing the
company's plan to convert its EDGA and EDGX electronic
communications networks into full-fledged exchanges.
Direct Edge claimed a record 12.9% matched market share of U.S.
trading in August as its chief rival, BATS Exchange, slipped to
10%.
Direct Edge's slice of the market has nearly tripled since last
September, when it claimed 5% of matched U.S. stock trades. The
company has built volume thanks to a competitive fee structure,
enabled by its use of flash orders.
The Jersey City, N.J.-based firm anticipates approval of its
applications in early 2010; it took about six months from
publication to approval for BATS.
While achieving exchange status "reflects the increase in Direct
Edge's market share and boosts our brand value," said O'Brien in an
emailed response, it also means a reduction in clearing costs.
With 1.5 billion to 2 billion securities changing hands each day
on Direct Edge's two platforms, clearing trades costs the company
around $10 million per year.
Expenses could fall substantially if EDGA and EDGX are
designated as exchanges, lowering costs for brokers and potentially
making Direct Edge a more attractive venue.
Revenue from market data is also viewed as a key component of
exchange status, though Direct Edge already collects most of this
income via its ownership of the ISE Stock Exchange, acquired in
December.
That deal gave the International Securities Exchange, an options
platform owned by Deutsche Boerse (DB1.XE), a 31.5% stake in Direct
Edge. Other owners include Knight Capital Group Inc. (NITE),
Citadel Derivatives Group, Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS) and
JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM).
SEC To Address Flash Trading
The practice of flash trading gives a select group of market
participants a fraction of a second to act on unfilled stock orders
before they're routed to other exchanges, and has drawn criticism
in recent months from lawmakers and regulators.
Nasdaq OMX and BATS voluntarily dropped their versions of flash
orders this month, making Direct Edge the only major U.S. platform
still offering the practice.
On Thursday the SEC plans to address the flash trading issue
with a proposal that would essentially "prohibit the practice of
displaying marketable flash orders," according to an announcement
posted on its Web site last week.
While O'Brien has argued in favor of the practice, he maintains
that a ban on flash order types wouldn't have much of an impact on
Direct Edge's overall business - the company estimates that flash
orders, while profitable, represent only about 5.5% of its total
matched trade volume.
"We trust [the SEC] will not rush to judgment, will garner as
much data as possible and seek constructive input from the industry
and investors," O'Brien said Monday.
-By Jacob Bunge, Dow Jones Newswires; (312) 750 4117;
jacob.bunge@dowjones.com