US Commodity Funds:Current Energy-Market Regulations 'Sufficient'
August 05 2009 - 9:08AM
Dow Jones News
The manager of U.S Commodity Funds plans to tell the U.S.
Commodity Futures Trading Commission that current energy market
regulations should remain unchanged.
"We are of the view that current regulation of the energy
commodity positions held by investors in futures by the exchanges
is sufficient," Chief Investment Officer John Hyland wrote in
prepared testimony. Hyland, whose funds include the U.S. Oil Fund
(USO) and U.S. Natural Gas Fund (UNG), also argues that exemptions
from position limits granted to index funds should be extended to
funds that track a single commodity.
The CFTC is holding its third day of hearings Wednesday to
determine whether and how to limit the size of holdings for index
funds, as well as swap dealers and other investors which do not
produce or consume the commodities underlying many derivatives.
USO and UNG sell shares on the New York Stock Exchange, then use
the proceeds to buy oil and natural gas futures. At times both
funds have held a large share of outstanding contracts in the front
month, leading some to blame them for recent extreme price
swings.
"In the absence of the (U.S. Natural Gas Fund) volumes, we
believe prices would have fallen because of the increasing supply,
increased inventories and weak demand relative to the previous
year," the Industrial Energy Consumers of America, which represents
large manufacturers, says in its prepared testimony for the
hearing.
In his testimony, Hyland makes the case that, by adding volume
to the oil and gas markets, the U.S. Commodity Funds have lowered,
rather than increased, volatility. The funds are described as
passive investors, buying or selling only when shares are bought or
sold on the stock exchange. Because the funds sell out of the front
month contract well before expiration, there is also no danger of
being forced to take physical delivery, Hyland wrote.
-By Brian Baskin, Dow Jones Newswires; 212-416-2453;
brian.baskin@dowjones.com