Vivendi GVT Offer Could Shake Up Brazil Telecom Sector
September 09 2009 - 11:47AM
Dow Jones News
The cash offer by France's Vivendi SA (VIV.FR) for Brazilian
telecom operator GVT Holding SA (GVTT3.BR) could shake up the local
industry, which most thought had settled into a three player
model.
Alternative operator GVT already had aggressive expansion plans
and, with the considerable ballast of Vivendi behind them, it could
accelerate the growth of its fixed-line telephone and Internet
services into cities dominated by the competition.
"This deal will give GVT much greater firepower to expand. We
weren't expecting a new outside player to come in," said Luciana
Leocadio, telecom analyst at the Ativa brokerage in Rio de
Janeiro.
However, the Vivendi offer is far from a done deal as minority
investors could reject it or a local competitor could make a rival
bid, analysts said.
Late Tuesday, Vivendi said it had made a friendly all-cash offer
of approximately EUR2 billion for GVT.
The news caught investors by surprise as most believed the
Brazilian telecom industry would be dominated by three groups from
hereon in -- Spain's Telefonica (TEF), Mexico's Telmex (TMX) and
Brazil's Oi (TNE). These firms were expected to consolidate and
gradually snap up assets as the opportunities arose.
Indeed, Telefonica had been linked with a possible bid for
GVT.
As a result, analysts do not think a rival bid is out of the
question.
"(In terms of margins), we would prefer to see consolidation in
Brazil's telecom industry, with incumbents participating in
M&A, rather than new entrants," said Vera Rossi, telecom
analyst at Morgan Stanley in New York.
GVT is a leading alternative telecom operator in Brazil with 2.3
million lines in service at end-June, offering fixed-line voice and
broadband.
The company operates in 72 cities in center-west, northern and
southern Brazil, and has plans to expand into the rich southeast of
the country.
Vivendi can bring valuable experience in running alternative
carriers. In France's Neuf Cegetel, it has perhaps Europe's most
developed market for alternative carriers.
Meanwhile, Vivendi's strong media wing will open up interesting
possibilities once IPTV regulations are in place, analysts
said.
"The new firm would be a real competitor to (Brazil's leading
cable TV provider) Net Servicos de Comunicacao S.A. (NET) (which is
part owned by Telmex), creating more competition," said Alex
Pardellas, telecom analyst at Banif Investimento.
Brazil offers obvious prospects for Vivendi, with a growing
middle class and broadband Internet at just 5% of the
population.
It also has an expanding cell phone market, although Vivendi
says it has no plans to develop a wireless network.
However, it is unclear if minority investors will sell as they
may demand a greater premium for waiving a poison pill clause in
the company's statutes.
GVT's controlling shareholders, Israeli investor Shaul Shani's
Swarth Group and Global Village Telecom (Holland) BV, have agreed
to tender a minimum of 20% of GVT's outstanding shares from the 30%
they own, but Vivendi's tender offer, priced at 42 Brazilian reals
($22.95) per share or a 15% premium on Tuesday's close, must still
attract enough small investors for the French firm to secure a 51%
stake.
"We think there is a possibility that this tender offer may not
take place at BRL42 per share, either because minority shareholders
do not approve the transaction under the current terms, demanding a
higher price, or due to a potential new offer from one of the
current telecom payers in Brazil," said Morgan Stanley's Rossi.
-By Alastair Stewart, Dow Jones Newswires; 5511 2847-4520;
alastair.stewart@dowjones.com