Securities Fraud Case First Filed By Scott + Scott Client Against Guidant Gets a Shock as FDA Refuses Freedom of Information Act
August 08 2005 - 8:37AM
PR Newswire (US)
FDA Denies Request for Information Regarding Faulty Defibrillators:
Electrical Flaws Would Cause Short Circuit in Device COLCHESTER,
Conn., Aug. 8 /PRNewswire/ -- Scott + Scott, LLC,
(http://www.scott-scott.com/) which filed the first securities case
in the United States District Court for the Southern District of
Indiana against Guidant Corporation (NYSE:GDT) due to its "recent"
catastrophic equipment failure and significantly belated
notification to physicians, was surprised to learn that a New York
Times Freedom of Information Act Request ("FOIA") to the Food and
Drug Administration ("FDA") was denied as such information was
deemed to be "corporate trade secrets." In the article written by
Barry Meier on August 6, 2005, the information sought by the Times
concerned the Guidant Ventak Prizm 2 DR, which the Company produced
thousands of from 2000-2002. Some of these devices had electrical
flaws that caused them to short-circuit. While Guidant claims to
have discovered the problem in 2002, Scott + Scott has information
that it may have known this issue existed in 2001, thus making the
hidden truth, known to defendants, more significant (more
information can be provided by attorney Neil Rothstein at the
contact info below). Many people with implanted Guidant devices
have contacted the firm. Any person affected by a faulty Guidant
device or a decedent's survivor may contact Scott + Scott directly.
As previously disclosed by Scott + Scott, a Senate inquiry led by
Senator Charles E. Grassley (R-Iowa), Chairman of the Senate
Finance Committee, has been ongoing and the Senator questioned why
such information was not being disclosed. The Medicines and
Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) is making urgent
inquiries into the product problems at Guidant and their
significance upon United Kingdom patients. If you would like
additional information, please contact the firm at 800/404-7770
before noon EST and thereafter, 800/332-2259 during office hours.
You may also contact attorney Neil Rothstein directly at (or cell
phone 619/251-0887) or attorney Amy K. Saba at (800/332-2259).
Scott + Scott has offices in Connecticut, Ohio and California. The
firm specializes in complex litigation including securities fraud
and represents foundations, individuals, corporations and pension
funds worldwide. Fred McCoy, president of Guidant's Cardiac Rhythm
Management division (according to the transcript of an interview
conducted by the Star Tribune, a Minneapolis newspaper) called
Guidant "A company of startlingly high reliability." McCoy said the
company has a "well-developed" quality system and a dedicated group
of engineers and scientists who relentlessly pursue improvement.
Defibrillators and pacemakers, he said, aspire to a 99% reliability
level over the course of several years, and tens of thousands of
people are alive today because of these therapies. Yet Scott +
Scott's investigation has yielded information that the Guidant
failure rate of 1% is based only upon the number of devices
returned to the Company for inspection. According to a source,
results from internal, unpublished post-market clinical trials show
a failure rate that suggests 8% is closer to the truth. This is due
to the fact that most devices are not returned to Guidant when a
patient dies and that the elderly who die rarely undergo an
autopsy, facts ignored by the Company when information was provided
to the public. Insider trading is now calculated at over $60
million. Moreover, the Wall Street Journal has reported that the
chief medical officer of Guidant sold more than $3 million of her
shares in May, just prior to the Company's announcement to doctors
of malfunctions in their defibrillators. This comes near the eve of
Johnson & Johnson's buyout of Guidant for about $25 billion. On
July 19, 2005, Johnson & Johnson gave little guidance on the
status of its acquisition of Guidant during a conference call.
Johnson & Johnson management later said that the scheduled
merger with Guidant might be delayed because of issues relating to
that company's recent product recalls. The deal is slated to close
during the third quarter, but Johnson & Johnson recently said
that the recalls may slow that schedule, and no longer promises a
third quarter close. Further, the insider trading at Guidant
indicates that those who did trade are not waiting for the buyout.
On June 16, 2005, Guidant recalled 50,000 faulty defibrillators due
to malfunctions in six different devices purportedly in response to
the New England Journal of Medicine's article that Guidant
continued to sell a defective product even after serious
malfunctions were reported. Various Guidant products continued
being recalled on June 16 and on July 18, new warnings were issued
and an additional 28,000 devices were to be recalled. Scott +
Scott, LLC's independent investigation of this matter is ongoing
and the possibility of additional information is likely. If you
purchased Guidant securities since 2001 or at any other time and
have questions, please contact Scott + Scott to learn your legal
rights, to discuss the matter with an attorney and to discover the
many advantages of Scott + Scott's representation. Anyone who was
harmed by a Guidant device can also contact the firm. There is no
charge or cost as our work is done on a contingency basis and must
be approved by the Court. DATASOURCE: Scott + Scott, LLC CONTACT:
Neil Rothstein, +1-619-251-0887 (cell phone), nrothstein@scott-
scott.com, or Amy K. Saba, +1-800-332-2259, Web site:
http://www.scott-scott.com/
Copyright
Guidant (NYSE:GDT)
Historical Stock Chart
From Jan 2025 to Feb 2025
Guidant (NYSE:GDT)
Historical Stock Chart
From Feb 2024 to Feb 2025